Home
Sponsored by Syngenta

The Potatocrop.com Knowledge Centre is a new learning tool to bring professional potato growers up to date with current issues. This module gives the latest advice on soil pest control.

Take the self-test at the foot of this article and you can gain two BASIS points.
Enter your name, BASIS registration number and DoB in the respective email message and send.

Falling resistance

Varietal resistance to the more aggressive 13_A2 blight is now significantly lower than previous indications suggest. Extensive testing over the past three years, as part of a Potato Council variety evaluation, has shown some of the most important existing commercial varieties are more susceptible to the new strains of blight than previously believed.

The vast majority of varieties trialled by a consortium of research establishments have seen their resistance ratings downgraded, with five previously strong contenders being reclassified from as high as an eight, down to a four. Of the existing varieties tested, outside the reference group, nothing received a score above five in the new evaluation, and 24 of the 28 varieties classified received a score of just three or four, compared to 19 varieties with a score of seven or eight previously.

Markies, Nadine, Pentland Dell and Premiere have all seen scores reduced by at least two, whilst Lady Balfour, which had been highly regarded as the standout blight resistant variety, was reduced from eight to four after a series of 12 tests with the 13_A2 blight strain.

More aggressive blight strains could lead to earlier leaf and stem loss, with higher financial costs, warn experts

Syngenta Potato Fungicides Technical Manager, Stephen Williams, believes this has important implications for blight fungicide timing and product selection. "In the past growers may have opted to use lower cost, less effective, options on varieties they believed to be relatively safe when blight pressure was perceived as low. With 13_A2 blight so predominant, no crops can be assumed to be safe at any stage, and reiterates the need for a continuous comprehensive spray programme," he advises.

"It also means that when the pressure is on, the more robust Revus chemistry will give all varieties the necessary level of protection. Growers should also be looking to use the higher 0.4l/ha rate of Shirlan if there is a perceived higher risk of infection," he advises.

Mr Williams added that if an infection period has recently occurred prior to application, growers should also consider that Revus has been shown to give some kick back activity, or to utilise a tank-mix with some cymoxonil.

"The new variety resistance scores may also influence priority for spray programmes," he adds. "If difficult weather conditions are stretching spray intervals, it will be imperative to treat the more susceptible varieties first and to use a robust programme that will prevent blight getting in."

Gary Collins at the Potato Council endorses Stephen Williams' comments. "It is important to review your blight strategy for the whole crop, bearing in mind blight pressure from known outbreaks, Smith Periods, the new resistance ratings and choice of chemistry. It will take more planning if field order is changed, but the objective is clean crops." Details of the full list of varieties is available on the Potato Council website blight hub, at www.potato.org.uk/blight

Varietal Resistance Top Tips

  • Review new varietal blight resistance information
  • Don't assume varietal resistance will give protection
  • Maintain robust spray programmes through any risk period
  • Prioritise susceptible varieties

Counting the cost of blight

The financial implication of just 1% foliar blight infection could be as much as £800 a hectare, calculates SAC. But if disease affects 1% of tubers, the penalty could escalate to over £3000 a hectare.

SAC potato pathologist, Ruairidh Bain, acknowledges the figures are largely hypothetical, based on a premium variety with an average market price of £130 when sound, but slashed to £70 if sold early to clear blighted stocks. "However, it clearly highlights the crucial importance of protection and the hidden costs of blight infection," he warns.

The economic cost of blight will be high if infection reaches tubers, which must be graded out or whole samples rejected

An early blight attack on foliage will incur extra costs from additional blight fungicides designed to dry up lesions and stop its spread – typically two extra sprays in the programme at a cost of over £80/ha including application. Crops in surrounding fields within a half mile radius will also require an upgrade in fungicide selection to offer greater protection, such as using Revus when a cymoxonil product may have sufficed, for example.

SAC also estimates potential costs of yield loss at around £650/ha where haulm destruction is required two weeks ahead of schedule, incurring a 5t/ha yield penalty.

Whilst the physical loss of grading out 2% of tubers as a result of blight infection might be worth less than £60/ha, the practical implication for growers may be the need to sell stock early – resulting in a massive price penalty. Furthermore, there is the practicality of identifying problems, when blighted tubers may not be apparent for several weeks after harvest.

Added to that, Dr Bain highlights the extra time and manpower required when grading out blighted samples, which could double costs to £15/tonne. "Growers also have to be aware that with any grading process there is the high risk of spreading problems, especially if secondary soft rot occurred." And if the decision is made to hold onto blighted stocks in store, continuous positive ventilation for an additional two weeks could add costs equivalent to £200/ha, followed by the need for expensive refrigeration to remove moisture.

"Evaluating losses due to blight is very subjective," he adds. "A few pounds spent in preventing foliar and tuber blight, by increasing blight applications or upgrading to a more effective product when an outbreak occurs, can save a large cost in the store."

Race wars

The current mix of A1 and A2 mating types of blight has raised the risk of sexual reproduction within blight populations – with the potential to create new more diverse blight strains that may prove more difficult to control with the threat of infection from soil-borne oospores.

Where specific races of A1 or A2 blight occur in isolation, they reproduce asexually – effectively creating clones of themselves with limited genetic variability. However, where mixed races occur, there is a greater chance of sexual reproduction and the creation of new strains, along with the development of oospores in the life cycle.

Over recent years A2 blight, particularly Type 13, had grown to over 70% domination of all blight populations. But research in 2010 showed that some of the A1 strains were in resurgence and that mixed race populations were more likely to be occurring.

Dr Ruairidh Bain of SAC attributes the appearance of substantially more aggressive genotypes, such as 13_A2 and 6_A1 as probably having originated from sexual reproduction.

Potato Council blight specialist, Gary Collins, reports that any dramatic increase in pathogen diversity has the potential to introduce strains that are more aggressive and fitter than the genotypes that have recently become dominant in the UK. "This would pose greater challenges on control programmes," he warns. "The experience of genotype 13_A2 is a stark reminder to growers of the consequences of population change."

Oospore spread
Oospores are of particular concern as they can survive in the soil between potato crops and hold the potential to initiate early infection. Data from the 2010 season has shown some evidence that oospores may have been involved in field infections, although it is early days and will need further investigation. Infection has been seen under controlled research trials by Sarvari Research Trust and SCRI, and is a common occurrence in mainland Europe.

Early infections low down on the stem or on lower leaves may be an early indication of oospore derived blight

"It is imperative that the industry remains vigilant for any suspected cases of early late-blight infections occurring from oospore sources," advocates Mr Collins. Most of the distinctive features of an oospore infection are similar to seed-borne blight, which include many small lesions per leaf, although a seed infection will be isolated to a single plant. Early identification is essential to pick up the symptoms of potential oospore initiated attack. Mr Collins also points out that oospores may be formed from blight infections on volunteers and outgrade piles, which makes their continued control so important. "The best method of minimising the risk of oospore derived outbreaks is to ensure that rotations between potato crops are long, and that all growing crops are kept clean," he advises.

"Growers and agronomists should be registered as blight scouts. A sample form any suspected ooospore outbreak can then be sent to a lab for diagnosis. If positive, the mating type can be identified, which will help to better our understanding of oospore infections in Britain." Mr Collins highlights there is further information on oospore blight infection on the Potato Council website, where growers can also register as a Blight Scouts.

Seed source
Blight infected seed stocks have been responsible for nearly 40% of early disease outbreaks, according to surveys in Holland. Although there is no national recording of blight infection on UK seed stocks, even very low levels could result in the development of infected plants.

The key concern with seed-derived infection is that the initial hot-spots occur within the crop – making spread less dependent on warm, humid weather, warns the Potato Council.

Application targets lower leaves

Alternaria sprays must target lower leaves to prevent infection getting in or spreading. Trials have shown spray angle and droplet size is more effective for optimum crop penetration in dense canopies, compared to simply increasing water volume to force spray into the plants.

Syngenta trials have shown that 200 l/ha is the optimum water volume for potato foliar spray programs; performance has been reduced at volumes of 400 l/ha.

Use angled nozzles to improve spray penetration in dense canopied potato crops

New hard-wearing Syngenta Potato Nozzles have been shown to give an optimum compromise of sufficient velocity to penetrate the boundary layer of large-leaved crops, but minimising the risk of droplets bouncing or rolling off the potato leaf.

Potato Fungicide Application Top Tips

  • Use angled nozzles Syngenta Potato Nozzles to target lower leaves
  • Use 200 l/ha water volume
  • Maintain 0.5m nozzle height above the foliage
  • Use drift-reducing Amistar Nozzles when spraying conditions are marginal

Quick action for early Alternaria attacks

Alternaria causes extensive spotting of leaves, leading to premature die-back of foliage - with consequential yield loss and lower tuber quality. Two forms of Alternaria occur in the UK: A. solani and A. alternata; both have similar symptoms and effects, although A. alternata typically attacks later.

Alternaria appears to be hitting potato crops earlier and with more damaging results, especially in the more susceptible varieties – in some instances leading to almost entire field loss

The predominantly soil-borne pathogen remains viable on volunteers and weed species between potato crops. It can spread on contaminated seed or movement of infected soil on machinery.

Some varieties appear especially susceptible, whilst weather conditions of periods of alternating wet and dry conditions have been favourable to Alternaria infection in recent seasons. In most crops Alternaria appears as extensive patches, although where disease is endemic whole fields in the UK have been recorded with 100% leaf loss.

What to look for this summer?
Early diagnosis of Alternaria infection is crucial as there is no curative option available. Application of specific fungicide treatments as soon as possible is essential to limit further development and spread.

The visible signs of Alternaria infection typically occur from mid to late July, although infection may have taken place some time prior to this. Look out for first signs of leaf spots on lower leaves infected from original soil spores.

Brown necrotic Alternaria lesions can appear very similar to magnesium deficiency. However, magnesium deficiency tends to occur on tissue between leaf veins (above, left), whereas Alternaria disease infection will spread across the entire leaf surface (right). Leaf curling may be confused with aphid damage

Rapid response to stop spread
Potato growers face an increasing risk of Alternaria, which appears to be attacking some varieties earlier and more aggressively than before. In Norfolk, agronomist Simon Alexander has reported successive years of early infection.

After witnessing devastating attacks in previous seasons, Simon Alexander is planning a fast response strategy this season to treat high risk crops as part of on ongoing programme

"In the past we have seen Alternaria coming into the crop late in the season, typically as it is beginning to senesce and hitting older lower leaves," he says. "But more recently infection occurred far earlier in the season and affected larger patches of the crop. It quickly spread across the whole field and led to early leaf loss." Alternaria infection can lead to yield loss, smaller tubers, variable dry matter and potential skin damage reducing marketability.

He warns that the earlier attacks mean growers face extended periods of high risk, when all the control options come into play. "Alternaria is now a major factor in agronomy decisions on susceptible varieties over a period of months. We are looking far more at proactive risk assessment to pinpoint high risk periods when we can prioritise applications to offer protection," he advises. "The aim is to protect clean upper leaves and to stop further spread across the field."

Potato Fungicide Application Top Tips

  • Watch out for the first signs of leaf spotting
  • Be especially vigilant during hot, showery conditions
  • Be aware of varietal susceptibility
  • Protect crops from disease spread

Watch out for blight attack

This season potato growers and agronomists will be able to get advance warning of local blight risk for the coming days, allied to a forecast of spray opportunities that will enable them to better schedule and select blight spray programmes, according to Syngenta Commercial Manager, Mark Bullen.

Use BlightCast to foresee potential high risk periods and plan spray programmes and product selection accordingly

Now available in the dedicated potato agronomy area of the company's new look web site – www.syngenta-crop.co.uk - BlightCAST provides growers and agronomists with a five-day forecast of localised weather conditions that are likely to give rise to Smith Periods and high blight risk. A simple colour-coded warning system alerts growers to the blight risk on any given day, along with a five-day spray window forecast.

"Until now the use of Smith Periods has been largely historical and an indication of when blight may already have infected the crop," reports Mr Bullen. "Now growers can be more proactive in product selection and application timing to protect crops and keep ahead of blight."

If growers know that there is a period of sustained high blight risk coming, then it is imperative that they are using the most robust fungicides possible, such as Revus, to counter the threat, he advises. "The spray window forecast will ensure they can make the applications at the most timely opportunity to give maximum protection through the high risk periods.

"If rain is coming, they can be confident that rainfast Revus will provide high levels of protection, when other fungicides may be washed off and leave the crop exposed at a time of the highest blight pressure."

The BlightCAST system was used by over 400 growers and agronomists last season. Mr Bullen advocates growers use BlightCAST in conjunction with the Potato Council Fight Against Blight website, which indicates where blight has been found in an area and which significantly increases the risk for other local crops.

Potato growers and advisors can register now for the free Syngenta BlightCAST service at the website www.syngenta-crop.co.uk

Potato blight BASIS self-assessment test

Use the following questions to check key points of understanding from the Potato Soil Pest Knowledge Centre:

1) Blight oospores are more likely to occur as a result of:

  • Dry weather conditions
  • Sexual reproduction between A1 and A2 blight
  • Planting crops from infected seed stocks

2) A2 blight strains now account for what percentage of the overall population:

  • Less than 50
  • 50–60
  • More than 70

3) Alternaria infection may be easily confused with:

  • Aphid activity
  • Magnesium deficiency
  • Drought stress

4) The optimum water volume for blight spray applications has been found to be:

  • 50 litres per ha
  • 200 litres per ha
  • 400 litres per ha

5) The estimated cost per ha of haulm loss to blight two weeks ahead of schedule is:

  • £300
  • £450
  • £650

Review Answers

1) B        2) C        3) A, B and C        4) B        5) C

If you have successfully studied this Knowledge Centre and undertaken the Potato Review/Potatocrop.com potato blight self assessment, click here to register for two BASIS points

BASIS ref:
CPD/19958/1011/h (valid to end May 2011)
CPD/20011/112/h (valid 1 June - 30 Sept 2011)

BASIS registered growers and agronomists can apply for up to a maximum of 12 CPD points from on-line learning tools. If you have already registered for previous Potato Review Knowledge Centre points and reached your annual limit, contact Syngenta for details of local meetings and briefings that provide valuable topical information and qualify for further CPD points. Register at www.syngenta-crop.co.uk
for more information

Sponsor's message

The Potato Review Knowledge Centre Soil Pest Update is sponsored by Syngenta. For topical application advice to get the best results from all your potato crop treatments this season, visit the website www.syngenta-crop.co.uk

Syngenta Crop Protection